By Andrew Williams
POLICE ARE WARRIOR PRIESTS
or "armed clergymen," in Alan Watts' exact phrase.
The police are your friends, see. They keep you between the lines so you
won't be noticed. If they do notice you, then they must become wrathful
and vengeful and will have to curse you loudly and beat you very, very
hard for, after all, is it not "God's wille" to punish the sinner?
It is logical, then, that many cops are Catholics: how well they've had
dinned into them the catechism of Original Sin. And how righteously angry
they can become when dealing with a suspected or confessed transgressor.
So you see, the church/state separation was actually dissolved when the
first cop with a religious bent was put on a beat.
In modern times, history has recorded how the police in New York City,
Chicago and L.A.--many good Catholics--hunted, hounded and haunted Billie
Holiday, Lenny Bruce and other great entertainers into early graves
because they dared to speak unpopular and unpleasant truths. And also
because they used substances that were not government-approved.
And let's not forget that "police riot" in Chitown in 1968. And of course
J. Edgar's masterstroke--COINTELPRO, which snooped on citizens who chose
not to blindly follow their leaders. (COINTELPRO is experiencing something
of a renaissance. Exempli gratia: the recent proposal by the FBI to
track the websites that library computer users visit. Computers, in fact,
like the one I'm using to send this essay.)
In truth, it is the police who cannot handle much light. We only kowtow to
them in fear and awe of their judicious might and the stern club of the
strong leader. Take the props away and they're just citizens in
ill-fitting blue uniforms. (In the case of undercover narks, ill-fitting
blue serge suits.)
When an artist speaks of "making the blue cars go away," s/he temporarily
and magically banishes the thrall which the People hold us under. That was
the great breakthrough of the 1960s: millions of young Americans learned
the answer to the question: "Who is wiser than all the buddhas, sages,
philosophers and prophets?" Or to rephrase in terms of the Zen koan: "Who
is the master who makes the grass green?" Whether you answer God or self,
it is, arguably, the same answer.
This is truth, but the good Catholic cop sees it as sacrilege. Your
sacrament is his road to perdition. (Bumper stickers sighted at
legalization rallies: "Support your local police--beat yourself up." "Bad
cop--no donut." "Am I under arrest? Can I go now?")
And now, a whole new factor has been added to the mix. The priesthood
molestation scandal that was one of the longest-running open secrets in
the history of the Catholic Church has broken onto the front pages of
America and is roiling the membership rolls.
Might we soon see Catholic cops beating Catholic priests into submission
and penance? Or does this now open sore of a scandal literally hit too
close to home? Either way, the Church has been publicly staggered by
revelations that are very old news to church insiders and literary
observers.
This is a day they knew was coming and for which they should have been
well prepared. So questions loom: How much faith will it take to forgive
the censured priests? And how will the "armed clergymen" who are of that
faith process this latest development?
After all, police have the same temptations and powers to obscure the
trails of their acts: threats of censure, intimdation and, of course,
threats and use of physical
force.
So whether it's the cop on the beat or the parish priest, parishoners of
all stripes would do well to question those who claim the role of
shepherd. And let none dare call it heresy to ask, "Who polices the
police?"